Notes

State-Based vs Value-Based Text Fields in Jetpack Compose

3 min read

Jetpack Compose provides two approaches for text input: value-based and state-based text fields. Here’s a breakdown of their key differences.

State Management

Value-Based Text Fields

  • Uses onValueChange callback
  • Manual state handling required
  • Developer maintains state in composables/ViewModels
  • Risk of async state update issues
  • Complex state synchronization across recompositions

State-Based Text Fields

  • Uses TextFieldState object
  • Automatic state management
  • Handles content, cursor position, selection, composition
  • Survives recomposition and configuration changes
  • Built-in state persistence

Text Transformations

Value-Based

  • Single VisualTransformation component
  • Combines input handling + output formatting
  • Manual offset mapping required
  • Complex for sophisticated transformation logic

State-Based

  • Separated into two stages:
    • InputTransformation: Filters input before committing to state
    • OutputTransformation: Formats text for display only
  • No manual offset mapping needed
  • Clear separation of concerns

Line Limits Configuration

Value-Based

  • Multiple parameters: singleLine, maxLines, minLines
  • Can be ambiguous
  • Potential for conflicting configurations

State-Based

  • Single TextFieldLineLimits parameter
  • Explicit min/max line definition
  • Clear, structured interface
  • Less error-prone

Secure Input

Value-Based

  • No built-in secure handling
  • Custom implementation needed for passwords
  • Manual character obfuscation required

State-Based

  • Built-in SecureTextField composable
  • Automatic character obfuscation
  • Disabled clipboard operations
  • Ready-to-use secure input handling

The official documentation recommends state-based text fields because they provide:

  • Simplified state management - No manual synchronization needed
  • Better architecture - Clear separation between input and output transformations
  • Reduced complexity - Unified configuration parameters
  • Built-in security - Native secure input support
  • Better reliability - Automatic handling of edge cases and lifecycle events

Code Examples

Value-Based Text Field

@Composable
fun ValueBasedTextField() {
    var text by remember { mutableStateOf("") }
    
    TextField(
        value = text,
        onValueChange = { text = it },
        label = { Text("Enter text") }
    )
}

State-Based Text Field

@Composable
fun StateBasedTextField() {
    val textFieldState = rememberTextFieldState()
    
    TextField(
        state = textFieldState,
        label = { Text("Enter text") }
    )
}

Secure Text Field

@Composable
fun SecureTextField() {
    val textFieldState = rememberTextFieldState()
    
    SecureTextField(
        state = textFieldState,
        label = { Text("Password") }
    )
}

Best Practices

  1. Use State-Based Fields for new development
  2. Migrate Existing Fields gradually to state-based approach
  3. Handle State Properly in ViewModels when needed
  4. Consider Security requirements when choosing field type
  5. Test Edge Cases like configuration changes and recomposition

Conclusion

State-based text fields offer a more robust, maintainable approach to text input in Jetpack Compose. While value-based fields are still functional, the state-based approach reduces boilerplate code and potential bugs, making it the preferred choice for new development.

Graph View

Backlinks